Caravaggio

Artists · 1571–1610 · 5 cities

Michelangelo Merisi, called Caravaggio after the town his family came from, changed how European painters used light. In about fifteen years in Rome, he painted saints as ordinary people, lit by harsh beams in dark rooms.

He was also violent, and in 1606 he killed a man. This thread follows him from Milan to Rome, then through four years on the run, and ends with where his paintings are now.

Training in Lombardy

1571–1592 · Milan and the town of Caravaggio

Caravaggio was born in Milan in 1571. When he was five, plague broke out in the city, and the family moved to Caravaggio, a small town to the east, but his father died there of the disease. At thirteen he was apprenticed to Simone Peterzano, a Milanese painter who claimed to have studied with Titian, the great Venetian. Painters in Lombardy, the region around Milan, liked plain, closely observed detail, and Caravaggio took that taste with him. You can see it in his Basket of Fruit, painted later in Rome, with its wormholes and wilting leaves. It hangs in Milan, in the Biblioteca Ambrosiana, a library and gallery founded by the cardinal who owned it.

Fame in two chapels

1592–1606 · San Luigi dei Francesi and Santa Maria del Popolo, Rome

Around 1592 he went to Rome, with no money and no name. At first he painted fruit and flowers for other artists. Then a cardinal took him into his household. In 1599 he won his first public commission: two large paintings for the Contarelli Chapel in San Luigi dei Francesi, the French church near Piazza Navona. In The Calling of Saint Matthew, Christ walks into a dim tax office, and a beam of light falls across the men counting money at a table. Nothing like it had been seen in a Roman church. Two more paintings followed for the Cerasi Chapel in Santa Maria del Popolo, by the city’s northern gate. In one, Saint Paul lies blinded on the ground under his horse. Both churches are free to enter, and the paintings still hang where he put them.

A death on the tennis court

May 1606 · Via della Pallacorda, Rome

Success did not calm him down. Police records show him arrested again and again, for carrying a sword without a permit, for throwing a plate of artichokes at a waiter, and for attacking people at night. On May 28, 1606, a fight broke out near the tennis courts on Via della Pallacorda, close to the Campo Marzio. It may have been about a bet, a debt, or a woman. Caravaggio killed a young man named Ranuccio Tomassoni with his sword, and he was badly wounded himself. He fled the city. He was sentenced to death in his absence, which meant anyone in the papal states could kill him on sight.

Sanctuary in Naples

1606–1607, 1609–1610 · Pio Monte della Misericordia, Naples

He went to Naples, a city ruled by Spain and outside the pope’s reach. It was then one of the largest cities in Europe, crowded and poor, and its patrons wanted him at once. For a new charity, the Pio Monte della Misericordia, he painted The Seven Works of Mercy. It crams feeding the hungry, visiting prisoners, burying the dead, and the other good works into one dark street corner, and it still hangs over the altar of the charity’s chapel. He also painted The Flagellation of Christ for a church in the city. It now hangs in the Museo di Capodimonte, the former royal palace on a hill above Naples.

On the run

1607–1610 · Valletta, Syracuse, Messina, Palermo, and Porto Ercole

In 1607 he sailed to Malta, an island ruled by the Knights of St. John, a military order of noblemen. He painted for them, including a huge Beheading of Saint John the Baptist for their church in Valletta, the only painting he ever signed. In 1608 they made him a knight. Within weeks he was in prison after another fight. He escaped over the walls and fled to Sicily, and the order threw him out. He moved from Syracuse to Messina to Palermo, painting altarpieces as he went. In 1609 he was back in Naples, where men attacked him outside a tavern and slashed his face. In July 1610 he set out by boat for Rome, hoping for a pardon, and died of a fever at Porto Ercole, on the coast of Tuscany. He was 38.

Where the paintings went

Today · London, Dublin, Berlin, and Paris

After his death, collectors carried his paintings out of Italy and north. The Supper at Emmaus, in which a young, beardless Christ is recognized at a table, is in the National Gallery in London. Amor Victorious, a grinning Cupid stepping over symbols of music, war, and learning, is in Berlin. The Death of the Virgin was rejected by the Roman church that ordered it, perhaps because the model for Mary was rumored to be a drowned woman from the streets. The young Peter Paul Rubens advised the Duke of Mantua to buy it, and it is now in the Louvre. The Taking of Christ was lost for two centuries. In 1990 it was found in a Jesuit house in Dublin, where it had been thought to be a copy, and it now hangs in the National Gallery of Ireland.