Architecture and design · 537–today · 10 cities
A great cathedral could take centuries to build. It often outlived the people who started it, and it could end up in a style they would not have recognized.
This thread visits ten of them, from Istanbul in the 500s to Barcelona, where the building is still going on. Each stop is one church and how it got built.
532–537 · Hagia Sophia, Istanbul
The story starts in Constantinople, the capital of the Byzantine Empire, now Istanbul. In 532, riots burned the city’s main church. The emperor Justinian had it rebuilt in under six years by two mathematicians, Anthemius of Tralles and Isidore of Miletus. Their church, Hagia Sophia, has a huge dome resting on a ring of forty windows, so it seems to float on light. It was the largest church in the world for nearly a thousand years. When the Ottomans took the city in 1453, it became a mosque. It became a museum in 1934, and a mosque again in 2020.
828–1204 · St. Mark’s Basilica, Venice
Venice looked east to Constantinople, and its great church shows it. In 828, two Venetian merchants smuggled the body of St. Mark the Evangelist out of Alexandria, in Egypt, reportedly hidden under pork to keep Muslim customs officers away. The city built a church to hold it, modeled on a church in Constantinople, with five domes and gold mosaics. Then, in 1204, a crusade led by Venice sacked Constantinople itself. The Venetians shipped home marble, columns, and treasure, including four bronze horses, and covered St. Mark’s with them.
1140s–2024 · Saint-Denis and Notre-Dame, Paris
The next great change in church building began just north of Paris. In the 1140s, Abbot Suger rebuilt the choir of the abbey of Saint-Denis, where the kings of France were buried. He used pointed arches and ribbed vaults, which let the walls become thinner and filled with stained glass. This was the beginning of Gothic. Twenty years later, Paris began Notre-Dame, on the island in the Seine, in the new style. In April 2019, fire destroyed its roof and spire. Carpenters and masons rebuilt them, largely with medieval methods, and the cathedral reopened in December 2024.
1401–1506 · Seville Cathedral
Gothic spread across Europe, and in Spain it was built over the past. Seville had been a Muslim city until 1248, when it was conquered by the kingdom of Castile. For more than a century its Christians worshipped in the old Almohad mosque. Then, in 1401, the cathedral chapter decided to build a church so big that people would think them mad. They kept the mosque’s minaret as the bell tower, now called the Giralda, and its courtyard of orange trees. The result is the largest Gothic cathedral in the world. It holds a tomb said to contain Christopher Columbus.
1420–1436 · Duomo, Florence
In Florence, the cathedral had a different problem. It had been designed with a dome wider than any built since ancient Rome, and nobody knew how to build it. For decades the church stood with a hole in its roof. In 1418, the city held a competition, and Filippo Brunelleschi, a goldsmith, won. Starting in 1420, he built the dome without a wooden frame to hold it up. He used two shells, one inside the other, and laid the bricks in a herringbone pattern so each ring supported itself. It was finished in 1436, and it is still the largest brick dome in the world.
1386–1965 · Duomo, Milan
Milan began its cathedral in 1386, and it took almost six hundred years to finish. It was built of white and pink marble from Candoglia, a quarry in the Alps, brought most of the way by water. Work went on slowly for centuries. Napoleon had the façade finished so he could be crowned King of Italy there in 1805. The last bronze door was put in only in 1965. In Milanese dialect, a job that never ends is still called a fabbrica del Duomo, a cathedral works.
1506–1667 · St. Peter’s Basilica, Rome
In Rome, the greatest building project of the age destroyed one of the oldest churches in Christendom. In 1506, Pope Julius II had the old basilica of St. Peter, more than a thousand years old, pulled down. He hired the architect Donato Bramante to build a new one. Over the next 120 years the job passed from one architect to the next, among them Michelangelo, who designed the dome. To pay for it, the church sold indulgences, which promised to shorten time in purgatory. Martin Luther’s protest against them helped set off the Reformation. The basilica’s interior was finished by Gian Lorenzo Bernini, who built the bronze canopy over the altar.
1675–1940 · St. Paul’s Cathedral, London
In London, a catastrophe made room for a new cathedral. The Great Fire of 1666 ruined old St. Paul’s, along with most of the medieval city. Christopher Wren, an astronomer turned architect, designed its replacement, with a great dome inspired by St. Peter’s. It was built from 1675 to 1710, and Wren lived to see it finished. On the night of December 29, 1940, German bombs set the City around it on fire. A photograph of its dome rising through the smoke became the defining image of the Blitz.
1882–today · Sagrada Família, Barcelona
Barcelona is still building its great church. The Sagrada Família was begun in 1882, and the next year the young architect Antoni Gaudí took it over. He threw out the plain Gothic design and spent the rest of his life on something stranger, with towers like honeycombs and columns that branch like trees. In 1926, he was hit by a tram, and he died with less than a quarter of it built. Work has gone on ever since, paid for by visitors’ tickets, with architects trying to work out what he intended.
1904–1978 · Hope Street, Liverpool
The last stop is Liverpool, which built two cathedrals in the 20th century, one at each end of Hope Street. In 1903, Giles Gilbert Scott, aged only 22, won the competition for the Anglican one. Building began in 1904 and went on until 1978, long after his death, and the result is the largest cathedral in Britain. The Catholics hired Edwin Lutyens, who designed a cathedral with a dome larger than St. Peter’s. Work stopped in the Second World War with only the crypt built. In the 1960s, Frederick Gibberd built a round concrete cathedral on top of it, nicknamed Paddy’s Wigwam.