Exiles

People and communities · 1302–today · 9 cities

Europe’s cities have always taken in people who could not go home: poets thrown out by their rivals, revolutionaries waiting for their moment, and refugees from war. Some cities became waiting rooms, where people sat for months hoping for a visa or a ship.

This thread follows exiles from Dante, thrown out of Florence in 1302, to refugees arriving in Europe today.

Dante

1302 · Casa di Dante, Florence

In the 1290s, Dante Alighieri, a poet, was also a politician in Florence. The city was split between two factions, and in 1302, while he was away on a mission to the pope, the other side took power. Dante was sentenced to exile and fined, and he was later condemned to be burned alive if he ever came back. He never did. For the rest of his life he moved between the courts of northern Italy. In exile he wrote the Divine Comedy, an epic journey through hell, purgatory, and heaven, and he put several of his enemies in hell. He died in Ravenna in 1321, and he is buried there. Florence has asked for his remains back ever since.

Lenin, Joyce, and Dada

1916–1917 · Spiegelgasse, Zurich

During the First World War, neutral Switzerland filled with refugees, draft dodgers, and revolutionaries. In 1916, on Spiegelgasse, a short street in Zurich’s old town, a group of artists and poets opened the Cabaret Voltaire. Disgusted by the war, they staged nonsense poems and noise, and they called the movement Dada. A few doors up the same street lived Vladimir Lenin, the exiled Russian revolutionary. Across town, James Joyce was writing Ulysses. In April 1917, after the tsar fell, the German government let Lenin cross Germany in a sealed train, hoping he would cause trouble in Russia. He did.

A passport for the stateless

1922 · Fram Museum, Oslo

After the First World War and the Russian Revolution, millions of people in Europe were refugees, and many had lost their citizenship. Without a passport, they could not legally travel or work. Fridtjof Nansen, a Norwegian polar explorer famous for crossing Greenland on skis, became the League of Nations’ first High Commissioner for Refugees. In 1922 he created a travel document for stateless people, which became known as the Nansen passport. More than fifty countries recognized it, and it helped hundreds of thousands of people. That year he won the Nobel Peace Prize. His polar ship, the Fram, is now in a museum in Oslo.

The exchange

1922–1923 · Nea Smyrni, Athens

In 1922 a Greek army that had invaded Anatolia was defeated by the Turkish nationalists, and Greek communities that had lived on that coast for thousands of years fled. In 1923 the two countries agreed to exchange their minorities, by religion rather than language. More than a million Orthodox Christians were sent to Greece, and several hundred thousand Muslims to Turkey. Athens was overwhelmed. The refugees built new districts on its edges and named them after the towns they had lost, such as Nea Smyrni, New Smyrna, and Nea Ionia.

Leaving Vienna

1938 · Belvedere, Vienna

In March 1938 Germany annexed Austria, and within days Vienna’s Jews were being beaten in the streets, robbed, and forced out of their jobs. About two thirds of the city’s Jewish population, well over a hundred thousand people, managed to emigrate before the war closed the borders. Most had to leave almost everything behind. Maria Altmann, a young woman from a wealthy family, escaped with her husband to the United States. Their family’s property, including a gold portrait of her aunt Adele by Gustav Klimt, was taken. Decades later, she won the painting back from Austria.

Marseille

1940–1941 · Boulevard d’Athènes, Marseille

When France fell to Germany in 1940, the north was occupied, and refugees from all over Europe fled south to Marseille, hoping to find a ship. They needed visas, exit permits, and transit papers, and they waited for months. Varian Fry, an American journalist, came to the city that summer with a list of artists and intellectuals in danger. Working from a hotel and then a small office, he helped about 2,000 people escape, among them the painter Marc Chagall, the philosopher Hannah Arendt, and the poet André Breton. The novelist Anna Seghers, herself one of the refugees, turned the endless waiting into a novel, Transit.

The last port

1940–1942 · Rossio, Lisbon

For refugees who made it across the Pyrenees and through Spain, the last stop was Lisbon. Portugal was neutral, and ships still sailed from its harbor to New York and South America. Tens of thousands of people waited in the city for a visa or a place on a ship, sometimes for months. They filled the cafés around the Rossio, the old central square. Many of them had got this far thanks to Aristides de Sousa Mendes, the Portuguese consul in Bordeaux, who issued thousands of visas against his government’s orders in June 1940. He was punished for it and died poor.

Brodsky’s winters

1972–1996 · San Michele, Venice

Exile did not end with the war. Joseph Brodsky, a young poet from Leningrad, was put on trial in 1964 for “social parasitism,” because the state did not consider poetry a job. In 1972 the Soviet Union expelled him. He settled in the United States, and in 1987 he won the Nobel Prize in Literature. For seventeen years he spent most winters in Venice, a city that reminded him of his own, and he wrote a short book about it, Watermark. He died in 1996, and he is buried on San Michele, the cemetery island in the lagoon.

Arriving now

2016–today · Amsterdam and Paris

The latest exiles are arriving now. The war in Syria, which began in 2011, drove millions of people from their homes. In 2015 and 2016, more than a million people came to Europe seeking safety, many of them on foot. One of them, the Syrian filmmaker Thaeer Muhreez, arrived at Amsterdam’s Centraal Station in 2016 after a long journey across the continent. In Paris, the Agency of Artists in Exile gives artists who have fled their countries a place to work, tools, and a community.