Crime and punishment · 1415–1834 · 7 cities
For four centuries, believing the wrong thing could get you burned. Catholic and Protestant churches, and the states behind them, tried and killed reformers, scientists, women accused of witchcraft, and people who read the wrong books.
This thread follows it from the burning of Jan Hus in 1415 to the end of the Spanish Inquisition in 1834.
1402–1415 · Bethlehem Chapel, Prague
In the early 1400s, Jan Hus, a priest and teacher at the university in Prague, preached at the Bethlehem Chapel in Czech, the language of ordinary people, not in Latin. He attacked the wealth and corruption of the Church. In 1414 he was summoned to a great council of the Church at Constance, in Germany, and promised safe conduct by the emperor. Once he arrived, he was arrested and tried. He refused to take back his views, and in July 1415 he was burned at the stake. His followers, the Hussites, rose up and fought off five crusades sent against them. A huge monument to Hus stands in the Old Town Square.
1481–1562 · Castillo de San Jorge, Seville
In Spain, Ferdinand and Isabella set up the Spanish Inquisition in 1478, and it held its first auto-da-fé, a public ceremony of judgment, in Seville in 1481. Six people were burned. Its first targets were converts from Judaism suspected of secretly keeping their old faith. For three centuries its headquarters in Seville was the Castillo de San Jorge, a castle by the river in Triana. Later it turned on Protestants. Around 1560 it burned a group of monks from a monastery near Seville who had been reading Lutheran books and translating the Bible into Spanish. The ruins of the castle are now a small museum under the Triana market.
1497–1498 · Piazza della Signoria, Florence
In Florence in the 1490s, a Dominican friar, Girolamo Savonarola, preached against luxury, corruption, and the Medici. When the Medici were driven out in 1494, he became the most powerful man in the city. In February 1497 his followers went from house to house collecting mirrors, playing cards, cosmetics, fine clothes, books, and paintings. They burned them all in a great bonfire in the Piazza della Signoria, the Bonfire of the Vanities. The pope excommunicated him, and Florence turned against him. In May 1498 he was tortured, hanged, and burned in the same square. A round plaque in the paving marks the spot.
1580 · Santa Maria Formosa, Venice
In Venice, the city’s government kept the Inquisition on a short leash. Veronica Franco was one of the city’s best-known courtesans, a woman paid for her company by rich and powerful men, and she was also a published poet. In 1580 she was brought before the Inquisition on a charge of witchcraft, made by her son’s tutor. She defended herself with confidence, and she was acquitted, probably helped by her friends among the city’s nobility.
1590–1720s · Castle Esplanade, Edinburgh
In Scotland, the fear of witches became a panic. In 1590 King James VI sailed home from Denmark with his new bride, and storms nearly sank his ship. He blamed witches, and dozens of people from North Berwick, a town east of Edinburgh, were tortured until they confessed. James later wrote a book about witchcraft. Over the next century and more, Scotland tried several thousand people for witchcraft, most of them women. Hundreds of the accused were strangled and then burned on Castlehill, at the top of the Royal Mile, by the castle. A small fountain there, the Witches’ Well, remembers them. In 2022 the Scottish government formally apologized.
1600 · Campo de’ Fiori, Rome
In Rome, the Inquisition put a former friar, Giordano Bruno, on trial. Bruno argued that the universe was infinite, that the stars were other suns, and that they might have planets with life of their own. He also held views about God that the Church considered heretical. He was tried for eight years and refused to take back his ideas. On February 17, 1600, he was burned alive in the Campo de’ Fiori, a market square near the river. In 1889 a hooded bronze statue of him was put up on the spot, facing toward the Vatican. The market still runs around it every morning.
1633–1642 · Arcetri, Florence
Galileo Galilei was luckier. With his telescope, he found evidence that the Earth goes around the sun, and he said so in a book in 1632. The next year the Inquisition in Rome found him vehemently suspected of heresy. He was made to kneel and take back his views, and the book was banned. He was not burned. He spent the last nine years of his life under house arrest in a villa at Arcetri, in the hills above Florence. He went blind there, but he kept working and wrote one of his most important books on physics. He died in 1642.
1680–1834 · Plaza Mayor and the Prado, Madrid
The grandest auto-da-fé of all was held in Madrid’s Plaza Mayor in 1680, before the young King Charles II, and it lasted from morning until late at night. More than a hundred people were sentenced, and some were burned afterward outside the city. By the time of the painter Francisco Goya, a century later, the Inquisition was weaker, but it was still dangerous. Goya was questioned about his painting of a nude woman, the Naked Maja. Napoleon abolished the Inquisition when he invaded Spain in 1808. The Spanish king brought it back after the French left, and it was finally ended in 1834.